Alan DeLozier, Executive Director (Seton Hall University)
- Rev. Michael Barone (Archdiocese of Newark)
- Rev. Augustine Curley, O.S.B. (Newark Abbey)
- Ms. Rebecca Driscoll (Lawrenceville Prep)
- Mr. Carl Ganz (Parish Historian, Immaculate Conception – Somerville)
- Dr. Maura Harrington (Independent Scholar, Commission Editor)
- Ms. Clare Holmes (Seton Hall University – Graduate Internship Student)
- Rev. Edward Jawidzik (Diocese of Trenton)
- Sr. Elaine Keenan, O.P. (Dominican Sisters of Caldwell)
- Ms. Mary Kinahan-Ockay (Saint Peter’s University)
- Rev. Michael Krull (Diocese of Metuchen)
- Msgr. Raymond J. Kupke (Holy Family Church – Florham Park)
- Ms. Brianna Lo Sardo (Archdiocese of Newark)
- Sr. Margherita Marchione, M.P.F. (Villa Walsh)
- Dr. Fernanda Perrone (Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey)
- Dr. Eileen Poiani (Saint Peter’s University)
- Ms. Kim Reamer (Caldwell University)
- Very Rev. Guy W. Selvester (Shrine of the Blessed Sacrament – Raritan)
- Ms. Tanya Taylor-Norwood (Diocese of Trenton)
- Deacon Carlo Santa Teresa (Immaculate Conception Seminary)
- Mr. Greg Tobin (AA, Author)
- Mr. Stephen Novosedlik (Byzantine Eparchy of Passaic)
- Rev. Joseph D. Wallace (Diocese of Camden)
- Msgr. Robert J. Wister (Seton Hall University)
Monsignor Francis R. Seymour, Chairman Emeritus (Archdiocese of Newark) [1937-2018]
Most Reverend Dominic A. Marconi, D.D., Chairman Emeritus (Archdiocese of Newark)
Ms. Sarah Beth Seymore, Administrative Assistant Emeritus
Updated as of February 1, 2021