Blueprint for a Catholic University

Ward, L. R. (1949). Blueprint for a Catholic university. St. Louis: B. Herder Book Co.

This is a good example of the Catholic response to the growing secularization of higher education and the difficulties that Catholic colleges (particularly in the United States) faced in maintaining their identity and purpose.  Ward argues that “merely trying to keep up, not get behind” (p. 7), particularly in terms of standardized testing and accreditation, has resulted in dismal “mediocracy” along with a siege mentality in which “simply to keep the faith” rather than moving forward became an end in itself.  He observes that “Merely being not non-Catholic, merely saving the faith, merely making not-bad men, is aiming at mediocrity and at best achieving it” (p. 8). Continue reading “Blueprint for a Catholic University”

The Idea of a University

Newman, J. H. (1931). Select Discourses from the Idea of a University. Cambridge, England: The University Press. Edited with an introduction by May Yardley.

This short book includes Discourses I, V-IX and “Literature: a Lecture” from Cardinal John Henry Newman’s seminal work: The idea of a university defined and illustrated I. In nine discourses delivered to the Catholics of Dublin II, including Discourses I, V-IX and “Literature: a Lecture”).  Continue reading “The Idea of a University”

The Myth of the University

Shore, P. J. (1992). The myth of the university: Ideal and reality in higher education. Lanham: University Press of America

This is an interesting and readable book, and although it was not well reviewed (largely on account of being impractical, and perceived as elitist and reactionary) I felt the author made some important points.  At the crux  is the dialectic between the university as an intellectual “community of scholars” (with a nostalgic look back to medieval times) and the socio-political reality of universities as training for profitable employment and the entry of universities into a competitive marketplace.

Continue reading “The Myth of the University”

What Does “Academic” Mean?

Pieper, J. (2015). What does “academic” mean? : Two essays on the chances of the university today. South Bend, Indiana: St. Augustine’s Press. (These are translations of lectures originally presented in 1950 and 1963).

Pieper asserts that there is continuity between our universities and Plato’s original academy, which is the basic model for our universities.  He holds that the intrinsic characteristic of Plato’s school was the philosophical way of looking at the world, and that the defining characteristic of an academic institution is that it is based on philosophy.  “A subject of study that has no philosophical orientation is not academic”.

Continue reading “What Does “Academic” Mean?”